Monday, 16 November 2026

How to process a multi-night dataset in SIRIL

Want to find something quickly on my blog? Use this page: https://undersouthwestskies.blogspot.com/p/how-to-find-topicpost-quickly-on-my-blog.html


M31 Andromeda Galaxy: My First Multi-Night Dataset in Siril

I've photographed M31, the Andromeda Galaxy, several times over the last few years. Every attempt has taught me something new, usually after several hours of confusion, a handful of forum searches, and the odd moment of staring blankly at the screen wondering what on earth I've just done.

This latest image marks an important milestone for me because it is the first time I have successfully processed a multi-night dataset in Siril.

The image below combines data gathered across three separate nights and, while there are undoubtedly quicker and more elegant ways to do this, I thought it would be useful to share exactly what I did in case it helps someone else who is currently wrestling with the same learning curve.

After all, that's what this blog is about: sharing successes, sharing mistakes, and hopefully helping all of us move forward a little faster.

 


M31 Andromeda Galaxy Capture Details

Date

12th November 2026

Location

Wembury Beach Car Park, South Devon

Observing Conditions

The weather was about as good as I could have hoped for:

  • Perfectly clear skies
  • Good seeing conditions
  • Bortle 4 skies
  • Temperatures just below 0°C

It was one of those sessions where the sky seemed determined to cooperate while the temperature tried its best to freeze the astrophotographer operating underneath it.

In fact, by the end of the session I had to scrape ice from the car windscreen before driving home.

 

Equipment Used

  • Zenithstar 61 II with 61A field flattener
  • Astromodded Canon 800D
  • Sky-Watcher EQM-35 Pro Mount
  • ASIAIR Mini
  • ZWO 120 Mini guide camera
  • RVO 32mm guide scope
  • Celestron Lithium Pro PowerTank
  • Three separate power banks for camera and dew control

 

Capture Settings

Across three separate nights I captured the following on each session:

Light Frames

  • 20 × 30-second exposures
  • 20 × 120-second exposures
  • 20 × 180-second exposures

Calibration Frames

  • 20 darks
  • 20 bias frames
  • 40 flats

Processing Software

  • Siril
  • Affinity Photo 1

 

Processing a Multi-Night M31 Dataset in Siril

This was where the real challenge began.

Until now, I had only processed single-night datasets. Combining multiple nights containing several different exposure lengths felt a bit like being handed three separate jigsaw puzzles, mixing all the pieces together and then being told there was supposedly only one final picture.

I searched forums and watched videos, but somehow managed to become more confused rather than less.

So eventually I did what many astrophotographers do when faced with uncertainty:

I made up my own workflow and hoped for the best.

Fortunately, it actually worked.

 

Stage 1: Create Master Lights for Each Night

For each individual night, and for each exposure length, I ran Siril's:

OSC_Preprocessing.ssf script

This calibrated, registered and stacked each set of images independently.

The result was a collection of calibrated and stacked master light files for:

  • Night 1
  • Night 2
  • Night 3

at

  • 30 seconds
  • 120 seconds
  • 180 seconds

In other words, I ended up with multiple completed master stacks ready for combination.

 

Stage 2: Create a Master Lights Folder

Next, I copied all those stacked master light FITS files into a brand new folder.

This became my working directory inside Siril.

Think of it as gathering all the ingredients onto the kitchen counter before attempting the recipe.

 

Stage 3: Build a Sequence

On the Conversion tab I:

  • Added all the master light files
  • Created a sequence called M31_Masters
  • Enabled Symbolic Links
  • Clicked Convert

Using symbolic links meant Siril referenced the original files rather than duplicating them, saving both time and disk space.

 

Stage 4: Register the Master Stacks

Before registration, I selected my cleanest 180-second master stack as the reference image.

(Exactly where I did this in the workflow is unfortunately lost somewhere between memory and old age. If I find the precise step again, I'll update this post!)

I then moved to the Registration tab and selected:

Global Star Alignment

before clicking:

Go Register

This aligned all the master stacks onto a common reference frame.

 

Stage 5: Stack the Registered Masters

On the Stacking tab I used the following settings:

Stacking Method

Average stacking with rejection

Normalisation

Additive with scaling

Output Normalisation

Enabled

RGB Equalisation

Enabled

Pixel Rejection

None

Weighting

Noise or Number of Frames

Then I clicked:

Start Stacking

 

Why I Chose These Settings

One thing I've learned over the years is that button-clicking without understanding is a dangerous game in astrophotography.

Sometimes it works.

Sometimes it produces magic.

Sometimes it produces modern art.

Here's the reasoning behind my choices.

 

Additive With Scaling

My 30-second, 120-second and 180-second master stacks all contained different brightness levels and background sky values.

Without normalisation, trying to combine them would be like asking three musicians to perform together while each played in a different key.

Additive with scaling aligns the background levels and scales brightness values so the stacks can work together without clipping bright regions such as M31's core.

 

Noise Weighting

This was the setting I was most interested in.

The idea is beautifully simple.

Longer exposures usually contain more useful signal, particularly in the faint outer dust lanes and halo structures.

Noise weighting evaluates the signal-to-noise ratio of each master stack and automatically gives greater importance to the cleaner data.

In theory, the deep 180-second stacks contribute more to the faint galaxy structure, while the shorter exposures help preserve cleaner bright-core detail.

At least that was the plan.

Thankfully, it seemed to work.

 

Output Normalisation

I enabled output normalisation to ensure the final combined image remained safely within Siril's floating-point data range.

My thinking was that I wanted to preserve every last scrap of dynamic range before applying a Veralux Hyperbolic Stretch later in the workflow.

 

Why I Disabled Pixel Rejection

By this stage I only had a small number of master files.

The original calibration and stacking runs had already dealt with:

  • Hot pixels
  • Satellite trails
  • Random artefacts

Pixel rejection algorithms generally perform best when larger numbers of frames are available.

I was concerned that running rejection again might remove legitimate data from M31 rather than noise.

So, I left it switched off.

 

The Result

Rather surprisingly...

It worked.

The final stack produced a clean linear master file ready for post-processing.

The very first thing I did was rename result.fit before accidentally overwriting it.

Experience has taught me that unnamed processing files have a life expectancy roughly equivalent to a chocolate teapot.

 

My Siril Processing Workflow

Once the master linear image was complete, this was my processing sequence:

  1. Open result.fit
  2. Enable AutoStretch display mode
  3. Rotate and crop
  4. Run Plate Solver
  5. Veralux Nox
  6. SPCC
  7. Cosmic Clarity Sharpening
  8. Silentium
  9. StarNet
  10. Return display mode to Linear
  11. Veralux Hyperbolic Stretch
  12. Veralux Curves
  13. Contrast Limited Adaptive Histogram Equalisation (CLAHE)
  14. Veralux Revela
  15. Save
  16. Veralux StarComposer
  17. HDR Multiscale
  18. Veralux Vectra
  19. Final Save

I will write a separate post explaining the thinking behind the order of these stages because there is quite a bit of reasoning behind it.

 

Lessons Learned

The biggest lesson from this project was that multi-night datasets aren't nearly as frightening as they first appear.

In reality, the process is simply:

  1. Calibrate and stack each night's data correctly.
  2. Treat those stacks as master subframes.
  3. Register them together.
  4. Stack them again.

Once I started thinking of each night's result as just another "light frame", the workflow suddenly made much more sense.

Like many things in astrophotography, the hardest part is often convincing yourself to start.

 

M31 Then and Now

One of the joys of astrophotography is seeing progress over time.

Below are my previous images of M31, shown in the order they were captured.

Looking back at old images can sometimes be uncomfortable, but it is also one of the best ways to see how far you've come.

Every image represents another lesson learned, another mistake overcome, and another step forward.

These were the first two images I did of M31 using my Samyang 135 lens on my Canon 800D before it was astromodded. The mount was a SWSA2i tracker and there was no guiding 


This was done with the Zenithstar on the SWSA2i - yep I did do that! 


And back to my latest one. I'm quite proud of it - it shows some substantial progress at long last


Final Thoughts

There's still plenty for me to learn and I'm sure there are more efficient workflows than this one.

If you process multi-night datasets differently, I'd genuinely love to hear about it.

Drop a comment below and share your approach. The astrophotography community is at its best when we're all comparing notes, sharing ideas and helping each other avoid the mistakes we've already made ourselves.

Until next time, stay safe, good viewing, and keep looking up.

Steve
PlymouthAstroBoy




Want to find something quickly on my blog? Use this page: https://undersouthwestskies.blogspot.com/p/how-to-find-topicpost-quickly-on-my-blog.html

Thursday, 5 November 2026

The skywatcher EQM-35-PRO mount control box

The new EQM-35-PRO mount control box has arrived

 So, the good news. 

My shiny new control box arrived this morning from Rother Valley Optics via DPD. 

It took just a day from order to arrival - how impressive is that? Big shout out to Rother Valley Optics for that. 


And it works! 

No more grinding sound.

No more binding.

No more jamming.

Yes, it is noisy - but it rotates smoothly! 

A win. 

I'll take it.


Meanwhile, I couldn't resist the temptation to take a peek inside the old one - I couldn't find any loose wires or broken solder points - so it must be some resistor or chip somewhere on the mother board - which is what Adam at RVO initially thought. 

"The EQM-35-PRO mount control box"

"Ooowww ......I wonder what it looks like inside?"

Can't see any loose wires or broken solder areas

Normal astrophotography service is now being resumed - as soon as we get a clear night! 

Postscript:

I managed to also successfully update the SynScan handset firmware as well - I had to hunt down a USB a to B type - but son-in-law came to the rescue - as he does on most things to do with IT and me. 😂

Monday, 2 November 2026

Sky-Watcher EQM-35 Pro DEC Motor Fault: Grinding, Binding and a Lesson in Mount Diagnostics

Sky-Watcher EQM-35 Pro DEC Motor Fault: Grinding, Binding and a Lesson in Mount Diagnostics

First of all, a huge shout-out to Adam at Rother Valley Optics (RVO). 

And then to Dave Woods at Dark Frames Ltd. 

Late on Friday evening I emailed both about my latest tale of astrophotography woe. This time the culprit was my Sky-Watcher EQM-35 Pro mount, whose DEC motor had suddenly decided that smooth tracking was overrated and had instead adopted a worrying repertoire of jamming, binding and grinding noises.

You can read about it in a previous post here: https://undersouthwestskies.blogspot.com/2026/10/skywatcher-eqm-35-pro-mount-grinding.html

As anyone involved in astrophotography knows, strange mechanical noises coming from your mount tend to produce the same emotional response as hearing an unfamiliar knocking sound from your car engine. You immediately fear the worst while simultaneously convincing yourself it's probably nothing.

Usually, it isn't nothing!

 


First Checks - Is the DEC Axis Mechanically Healthy?

Early Saturday morning I began investigating.

With the DEC clutch disengaged, I manually rotated the DEC axis through its full range of motion. To my relief it rotated freely and smoothly.

That was an encouraging sign.

If the internal casting, main shaft, brass bushings or synthetic bearings had suffered a catastrophic failure, I would have expected roughness, sticking, excessive resistance or obvious binding.

Instead, everything felt healthy.

That allowed me to narrow the search area considerably. The problem seemed more likely to be isolated to one of three areas:

  • The DEC motor itself
  • The transfer gear assembly
  • The electronic control system

In troubleshooting terms, this was my first small victory. The list of possible culprits had become shorter.


The Internet Rabbit Hole

A little internet research revealed something interesting.

Stepper motors can produce a truly horrible grinding noise when they electronically stall. Rather than rotating normally, they effectively lose synchronisation and shake violently.

One possible cause is inadequate power supply.

However, I was running from a fully charged Celestron Lithium Pro PowerTank, so power starvation seemed unlikely.

Other possibilities sounded rather less appealing.

A broken cable.

A cracked solder joint.

A bent connector pin.

Any of these faults can cause a motor to lose one of its electrical phases. The result is a motor that appears to have completely forgotten its purpose in life, vibrating angrily backwards and forwards while producing noises that suggest expensive things are happening.

Gulp.

"The DEC motor unit of the EQM-35_PRP skywatcher mount"


Taking the Motor Apart... Slightly

At this point I decided it was time for a little controlled exploration.

I removed the plastic DEC motor cover and detached the brass gear mounting assembly, leaving access to the motor and its vertical output shaft.

Now, this was venturing into territory normally occupied by braver people than me.

Or perhaps more reckless people.

Possibly both.

My assumption was that the gear should not spin completely freely. Instead, I expected a firm, uniform, clicky resistance as I rotated it by hand, caused by the motor's internal magnets passing through their positions.

Sure enough, that's exactly what I found.

The motor gear felt consistent and healthy.

The mating gear mounted to the metal casing also rotated freely. The grub screws were secure, there was no wobble, no excessive play and no signs of misalignment.

So far, so good.


Then came the important test.

With the gear assembly removed, I powered up the motor.

The vertical shaft spun smoothly.

Quietly.

Continuously.

No grinding.

No catching.

No stalling.

No unpleasant mechanical drama.

At that moment things started looking considerably more positive. The motor itself appeared to be working perfectly.

Then a friend got in touch and suggested it was the motherboard - a common reason why skywatcher mounts will sometimes behave this way, apparently - was news to me - hadn't even considered that option. 

 




Adam's Diagnosis

Later on Saturday morning Adam replied to my email and asked me to send a video showing the mount's behaviour.

After reviewing the footage, his assessment was impressively quick and reassuringly logical.

The likely causes were:

  • A fault in the DEC cable
  • A fault on the mount control board - which my friend had already suggested
  • A failure involving the bearings or magnets around the worm-drive motor assembly

His recommendation was simple.

Before ordering parts or dismantling anything further, determine whether the problem was electronic or mechanical.

A classic process-of-elimination exercise.

He suggested the following test:

"Unplug the DEC cable from the motor mount box and plug the RA cable into the DEC motor instead. Then use the hand controller to command an RA slew."

Simple. Elegant. Effective.


The Decisive Test

There were only two possible outcomes.

Result A

The DEC motor spins perfectly when commanded through the RA output.

If that happened, the motor and gears were physically healthy and the fault would lie elsewhere.

Result B

The same grinding and sticking occurs.

That would indicate a genuine mechanical fault involving the motor, gear train or related hardware.

 

By this stage I was already leaning heavily towards Result A.

And that's exactly what happened. The DEC motor ran perfectly.

No binding.

No grinding.

No hesitation.

No drama.

I then repeated the test using the second cable.

Exactly the same result. Result A again.

 

Process of Elimination

At this point the evidence was becoming rather difficult to ignore.

The motor appeared healthy.

The gears appeared healthy.

Both cables appeared healthy.

That left one increasingly suspicious candidate standing alone under a bright interrogation lamp.

The motherboard.

Which, incidentally, was exactly where Adam's and my friend's experience had pointed from the start.

Sometimes experience simply gets you to the destination much faster than trial and error.

 

"The EQM-35-PRO Control Unit"

The Solution

A replacement controller board has now been ordered from Rother Valley Optics.

With a little luck, swapping out the board will bring the EQM-35 Pro back to life and return it to its proper role of tracking galaxies and nebulae rather than impersonating an angle grinder.

Fingers crossed.


Going forward

At this point, having seen how smoothly my friend's EQM-35-Pro mount operates  - it had been rebuilt by Dave at Dark Frames Ltd, I attempted to convince the boss that a rebuild was a good idea and having spent an hour bending her ear about all the advantages of doing it, over a coffee - I was thrilled to get the seal of approval. 

 

A Final Word About Customer Service

Throughout this entire process Adam at Rother Valley Optics has been exceptional.

Multiple emails on Saturday.

Fast responses.

Clear instructions.

Follow-up emails first thing Monday morning.

This is exactly the kind of customer service that keeps people returning to specialist astronomy retailers.

When things go wrong, it is easy to discover who simply sells equipment and who genuinely supports their customers.

Rother Valley Optics have certainly done the latter and my deep thanks and appreciation go to him.


I missed a phone call Monday evening from Dave Woods at Dark Frames Ltd - I'll explain why in a minute. But again, excellent customer service. Tuesday morning, a detailed email in my inbox - outlining what would be done to my mount, how much it would cost, what differences it would make to performance  - excellent stuff. 

Under normal circumstances I would have immediately contacted him and actually taken the mount up to him in the Portsmouth area. I mean I have seen the difference his work makes to a mount - astounding transformation. 

But alas, things have conspired against this. 

Welcome to the word of subsidence, unexpected collapsed patio areas, falling walls and lots of unbudgeted for expenses suddenly on the horizon.  

It isn't a big hole by cornish sink hole comparisons but the walls are cracked, the patio is a goner - the drain shaft seems intact fortunately. Builders are now on site - concrete is on order and so the process of rebuilding starts. The emergency contingency fund is now down several thousands of pounds. New wall, new drainage pipes and channels, new concrete pad across whole patio area. New fencing. New patio! Ouch!

Sometimes you have years like this one - 2026 has been the year of a new dishwasher, new fridge, new microwave, new car windscreen, new side panel repair to motorhome, two collapsed trees in garden, a new mount control unit and now the patio and wall rebuild. And there is still November and December to go - aargh!

And so, much to my disappointment, the rebuild of my EQM-35-Pro is on a temporary hold. I'm not quite sure how long temporary is at the moment - but probably not this winter season. However, the boss has given it the go ahead - so Dave, it will happen but not immediately - unfortunately! 

For thirty years we had decking over the entire area and so never spotted that the patio had started to collapse. When we lifted the decking, an area of it had collapsed about five inches - but it seemed stable. Clearly not - recent heavy rains had been washing down underneath it - and well, the rest, as they say, was inevitable. Five inch thick concrete crazy paving patio suspended over a rather large void. And two hitherto undiscovered manhole covers and drains - previous house owners had covered them over with crazy paving! Thank God we hadn't jumped in that area - I'm surprised it took my weight when I walked across it - so are the builders - cheeky muppets! 

Only the Ivy had been holding up the wall - the bottom part had twisted and fractured in several places. The builders touched the wall - and it became very obvious it was unsafe and was going to have to come down as well. Ho hum! 

 

What I Learned from the mount situation

Oddly enough, I have come away from this 'failing mount' experience with something valuable.

Confidence.

A few days ago, the idea of taking even part of my mount apart would have filled me with dread.

Now I've inspected the motor, removed components, carried out fault-finding tests and learned a fair bit about how stepper motors and mount electronics actually work.

That's probably a dangerous development.

If I'm not careful, I'll start convincing myself that a full strip-down, bearing inspection and regrease is a perfectly sensible weekend activity. On the other hand - sending it to Dave Woods seems a far more sensible option frankly and so that remains the plan. 

Let's not get carried away with an over appreciation of my 'assumed' engineering skills! 

One astronomical crisis at a time.


Meanwhile, I'm back off onto the 'tea and biscuits' shift'. Its very cold outside, there is a brisk chilly northerly wind and our builders are being heroes. 

And my deep thanks to Adam at Rother Valley Optics, a couple of members of the Plymouth Astronomy Society and Dave Woods of Dark Frames Ltd. 

Will the new control unit solve the problem? Find out here: https://undersouthwestskies.blogspot.com/2026/11/the-skywatcher-eqm-35-pro-mount-control.html

Saturday, 31 October 2026

Skywatcher EQM-35-PRO mount grinding and jamming

 Distraught. Gutted. Nasty sick feeling in the pit of my stomach. 

My EQM-35-PRO mount has gone haywire. Last night whilst imaging M31 down at Wembury Beach, the decination bit of the mount suddenly started grinding and binding before coming to  a complete halt. 

Today, I have just done a simple strip down to try and work out whats happening. These two videos show the issues. 


Ho hum. Lets hope there is someone out there who can help. 

This post outlines when I got the mount. https://undersouthwestskies.blogspot.com/2025/04/the-eqm-35-pro.html

And this post - shows the solution to the above problem, thanks to Adam at Rother Valley Optics: https://undersouthwestskies.blogspot.com/2026/11/sky-watcher-eqm-35-pro-dec-motor-fault.html

Sunday, 25 October 2026

Brian Cox: Emergence. A Night of Snowflakes, Galaxies and Cosmic Humility - a review

 Brian Cox: Emergence. A Night of Snowflakes, Galaxies and Cosmic Humility

I’d been waiting almost a year for this talk.

And it didn't disappoint.

As the 2,500-strong audience filtered in from the arena bars, foyers and cloakrooms, there was a palpable buzz in the air. This wasn't just another evening lecture. It felt more like the opening night of a major theatre production, albeit one about quantum mechanics, galaxies and the nature of reality itself.

Below are my thoughts on the evening, along with a summary of some of the ideas that stayed with me long after the lights came up.

A Quick Show Overview

Emergence is a two-hour live science and cosmology show (plus interval) exploring how extraordinary complexity emerges from remarkably simple beginnings. A heady mixture of cosmology, physics, biology, philosophy and a dash of history, all wrapped in stunning visuals projected across an enormous ultra-wide screen. Real-time imagery from the ISS sat alongside breathtaking NASA footage and the latest telescope images. Add a powerful musical score and the whole thing felt part science lecture, part cinematic experience.

At times it was genuinely awe-inspiring.

 

"Brian Cox explaining The big Bang"

From Snowflakes to the Structure of the Universe

The central theme of the evening was deceptively simple:

How do beautiful, complex structures emerge from a universe governed by relatively simple laws?

Professor Cox launched straight into this question with a stunning visual sequence. We zoomed into a snowy Prague street in 1610, crossing a bridge during a winter storm. It was an opening that immediately pulled the audience into the story.


The entire show was framed around a question posed by Johannes Kepler more than 400 years ago.

Why do snowflakes almost always exhibit six-fold symmetry?

Why six corners? Why not five or seven? Why order instead of chaos?

What initially sounds like a curious observation about winter weather becomes something much bigger. It's really a question about why the universe contains patterns at all.

Cox discussed Kepler's 1611 essay The Six-Cornered Snowflake, explaining how snowflake geometry isn't an accident. The answer lies deep within the structure of water itself. Apparently, the angle between hydrogen atoms in a water molecule is around 105 degrees. That microscopic arrangement ultimately dictates the familiar hexagonal pattern of snowflakes.

Who knew?

The striking idea was that the same laws shaping tiny ice crystals also underpin structures across the cosmos. Nature seems to rhyme with itself. Patterns repeat across vastly different scales, from snowflakes drifting through Earth's atmosphere to spiral galaxies rotating hundreds of millions of light years away.

 

A Journey Inwards

Backed by superb visual effects, Cox then steered us into the world of reductionism.

Imagine dismantling a clock to understand how it works.

Only instead of gears and springs, we were stripping a snowflake apart.

First molecules. Then atoms. Then electrons and quarks. Smaller and smaller still, descending into the strange quantum realm where everyday intuition quietly packs its bags and leaves the building.

This section covered some of the fundamentals of quantum mechanics and Planck's work. I won't pretend I followed every twist and turn, but I certainly learned a thing or two.

There were moments when the concepts became challenging, but that's hardly surprising when you're discussing the deepest levels of reality.

 


Enter Emergence

This led to the evening's central concept: emergence.

The basic idea is that understanding individual components doesn't necessarily tell you how a complex system will behave.

You can understand every molecule in a hurricane and still fail to predict the hurricane.

You can study a single neuron and still not explain consciousness.

Likewise, looking at one particle in isolation doesn't necessarily explain the astonishing structures that appear when trillions upon trillions of particles start interacting.

Complexity emerges.

Like countless notes forming a symphony or individual pixels creating a masterpiece, simple building blocks interacting under simple rules can create staggering complexity.

And that was only the first half.

 


Zooming Back Out Again

After the interval, the direction of travel reversed.

Instead of descending into the microscopic world, we accelerated outwards from it, across the cosmos.

And what a journey it was.

From quantum fluctuations and the birth of structure in the early universe, we scaled up through galaxies, galaxy clusters and the vast cosmic web itself. Along the way came black holes, cosmic evolution and the changing expansion rate of the universe across more than 13 billion years of history.

The scale shifts were extraordinary.

One moment you were contemplating subatomic particles. The next you were looking at structures so vast they make entire galaxies seem insignificant.

The evening eventually arrived at one of cosmology's biggest open questions: the possibility of multiple universes.

Not a bad place to end up after starting with a snowflake.

 


The Most Important Message

Perhaps the most powerful idea of the entire evening wasn't scientific at all.

It was Cox's repeated emphasis on three simple words:

"I don't know."

Kepler couldn't fully explain the symmetry of snowflakes.

Modern scientists still don't have all the answers either.

And that's exactly the point.

According to Cox, this willingness to say "I don't know" sits at the very heart of science. Progress depends upon uncertainty. Discovery begins where certainty ends.

Dogma shuts doors.

Curiosity opens them.

As someone who spends many nights under dark skies photographing objects we are still only beginning to understand, that message resonated deeply.

Uncertainty is a primary driver of progress and ‘assuming absolute certainty’ stalls human evolution. We all need to embrace what we don’t know – a radical necessary strength if we are to evolve further.

Splendid stuff



Yes, The Fermi Paradox Made an Appearance

Naturally, the question of alien civilisations surfaced.

Why, in a galaxy containing hundreds of billions of stars, have we found no convincing evidence of other spacefaring civilisations?

Cox touched on several possible explanations.

Perhaps there are "great filters" that most intelligent species fail to overcome. Resource depletion, climate change, technological risks and even artificial intelligence all entered the discussion.

But there was another intriguing possibility.

Complex life on Earth required roughly 3.5 billion years of relative stability. Perhaps that level of long-term cosmic calm is simply rare. Maybe most planets experience catastrophic interruptions long before intelligent life has a chance to emerge.

If so, we may be far rarer than we imagine.

 


The Pale Blue Dot

The evening concluded with reflections on Carl Sagan's famous Pale Blue Dot.

This was perhaps the most emotional section of the show.

We are, as Sagan famously said, made of star stuff.

The carbon in our bodies was forged inside stars. Every atom in us has a cosmic history stretching back billions of years.

And yet this tiny world remains the only home we have ever known.

Given the absence of evidence for other advanced civilisations, human consciousness may be an extraordinarily rare phenomenon. The universe has spent 13.8 billion years arranging atoms into a form capable of looking back and asking questions about itself.

That's quite a responsibility.

The message was simple: if intelligent life is rare, then preserving it matters. We all carry the shared responsibility, nae duty, to care for this fragile and very rare planet.

Human consciousness - an exceedingly rare cosmic anomaly.

 


Science, Truth and a Few Uncomfortable Moments

Somewhere amid the snowflakes, galaxies and multiverses, Cox also addressed more modern issues - scientific misinformation and denialism; the challenge of identifying reliable knowledge in an increasingly noisy world.

His argument was that science progresses precisely because it has developed methods for removing human bias and testing ideas against observation and mathematics.

As somebody who failed O-Level Maths five times before finally scraping a pass, I have to admit there were moments during this section when I was feeling distinctly twitchy – can a mathematically challenged person step up to his human scientific responsibilities in a meaningful way?

 


So, What Did I Take Away?

More than anything, I came away loving the "I don't know" principle. The willingness to embrace uncertainty isn't weakness. It's strength. It's the engine of curiosity and the fuel of progress.

Too often we celebrate certainty when perhaps we should celebrate thoughtful doubt instead.

I also found the Pale Blue Dot argument especially powerful given today's political climate. Looking at humanity from a cosmic perspective makes our divisions seem surprisingly small, almost petty.

We're all passengers on the same tiny spacecraft, hurtling through an unimaginably vast universe together.

That is a perspective worth keeping.

And I suspect it will make this winter's astrophotography sessions a little more reflective than usual.

Oh, and one fact stood out for me – Cox and others believe that we are the only planet in our entire galaxy that has ‘goldilocks’ conditions to sustain life of this complexity.

Think about it – 100 to 400 billion stars in the milky way. NASA Kepler telescope data suggests each of these has at least one planet orbiting it – and billions of these exist within a ‘habitable’ zone i.e. the region around a star where liquid water could potentially pool on a rocky surface.

Mind blowing!

Go a little further – NASA estimate 2 trillion galaxies in our observable universe - multiply 2 trillion galaxies by an average of roughly 100 billion stars per galaxy, the observable universe contains an estimated 10²² to 10²⁴ stars (more than all the grains of sand on Earth). And remember, the "observable universe" is only the bubble of space from which light has had enough time to reach us since the Big Bang (about 93 billion light-years across). The total universe outside our horizon is likely much larger or potentially infinite. Mind blown! Official!

 


Final Thoughts

Technically, the production was superb.

The giant HD LED screen, real-time data visualisations, deep-space imagery and carefully crafted soundtrack elevated the experience far beyond a conventional lecture. At times it felt more like an immersive documentary than a science talk.

Intellectually, it was challenging too. Some of the concepts required serious concentration, and occasionally I found myself struggling to process one idea before the next arrived. There was definitely some heavy lifting involved.

The lighter moments helped. A few references to Cox's D:Ream days brought welcome laughs and prevented things becoming too dense.

My only real disappointment?

No Q&A session. For a show built around curiosity, it felt like a missed opportunity.

But honestly, that's a very minor criticism.

This was an evening packed with wonder, perspective and genuinely thought-provoking ideas.

I absolutely loved it.